Auto Stocks and the Car Cycle: Ford, GM, Toyota and Tesla vs Consumer Discretionary (XLY) and the S&P 500

Ford has one of the clearer multi-year cycles on the site. We compare Ford, General Motors, Toyota and Tesla with the consumer discretionary fund XLY and with SPY.

Car sales rise when consumers feel confident and credit is cheap, and fall hard in recessions, which makes auto stocks some of the most cyclical shares in the market. We measured the multi-year cycles of the long-listed automakers on the site and compared them with the Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR (XLY), the sector that includes carmakers, and with SPY.

  • Ford has one of the clearer cycles on the site: about 5.5 years long with roughly a 2% chance of luck, and swings of ±22% around trend.
  • General Motors (since its 2010 return to the market) shows a weak 3.8-year cycle with unusually regular turning points; Toyota a weak 6.2-year one.
  • Tesla swings about ±55% around trend but has no regular period; newer electric-vehicle makers have too little history to test.
  • Automakers’ biggest drawdowns were often not market-wide: Ford fell 56% from 2014 to 2018 while XLY rose 44% and SPY 25%.
  • In recessions they crashed hardest: Ford −77% from April 2008 to January 2009, against −40% for SPY.

Why auto stocks are cyclical

A car is a large, postponable purchase, usually financed. When the economy is strong and interest rates are low, sales rise; when unemployment or rates rise, buyers keep their old cars longer. Automakers have high fixed costs, factories, unions, pensions, so falling sales hit profits hard (operating leverage). Add model cycles, supply shocks such as the 2021–22 chip shortage, and the costly transition to electric vehicles, and auto stocks swing far more than the economy itself.

Automakers against XLY and SPY

Automakers and other consumer discretionary stocks: multi-year cycle statistics, with the Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR (XLY) and SPY. "Chance it's luck" = share of random-walk simulations producing a cycle at least as strong; correlations compare the swings around each symbol's long-term trend.
SymbolNameComplete yearsStrongest cycleChance it's luckCycle ratingSwing around trendTypical peak spacingDeclines during S&P sell-offsMoves with XLYMoves with SPY
FFord Motor Company535.5 yrs2%Moderate±22%2.7 yrs14 of 160.480.55
GMGeneral Motors Company153.8 yrs7%Weak±19%3.3 yrs4 of 50.730.78
TMToyota Motor Corp496.2 yrs11%Weak±11%3.4 yrs8 of 130.570.68
TSLATesla Inc156.3 yrs17%None±55%3.8 yrs3 of 30.690.60
HDThe Home Depot Inc447.5 yrs3%Moderate±19%2.8 yrs7 of 90.560.70
AMZNAmazon.com Inc284.3 yrs7%Weak±39%1.8 yrs5 of 80.160.47

XLY itself shows no reliable cycle, because it is dominated by Amazon, Tesla and Home Depot rather than carmakers. The automakers are much more cyclical than their sector: Ford’s swings are more than twice the size of XLY’s.

Spotlight: Ford, 53 years of the car cycle

Ford has the longest history in the group. Its strongest cycle is about 5.5 years long, and 14 of its 16 major drawdowns coincided with broad S&P 500 sell-offs. But the longest decline was its own: from August 2014 to December 2018 the stock lost 56% while the market rose, as U.S. car sales peaked and investors worried about the shift to electric vehicles.

F: major declines (monthly closes, reversals of 30% or more), latest first, with other symbols over the same months. "–" = no data for that period.
Peak – troughMonthsFXLY same monthsSPY same monthsF recovery to next peakDuring S&P sell-off
Aug 2022 – Oct 202314−36%−2%+6%+79%Yes
Dec 2021 – Jun 20226−46%−33%−21%+37%Yes
Apr 2019 – Mar 202011−54%−18%−12%+330%Yes
Aug 2014 – Dec 201852−56%+44%+25%+37%Yes
Dec 2010 – Jul 201219−45%+16%+10%+88%Yes
Apr 2008 – Jan 20099−77%−39%−40%+798%Yes
Jun 2007 – Mar 20089−39%−22%−12%+44%Yes
Dec 2003 – Jul 200631−58%+2%+15%+41%No

GM and Ford: the same cycle

General Motors and Ford move together: from November 2017 to March 2020 GM lost 52% and Ford 61%; from November 2022 to October 2023 both lost 30% while XLY and SPY rose. GM’s turning points have been the most regularly spaced in the group, about 3.3 years apart.

GM: major declines (monthly closes, reversals of 25% or more), latest first, with other symbols over the same months. "–" = no data for that period.
Peak – troughMonthsGMF same monthsXLY same monthsSPY same monthsGM recovery to next peakDuring S&P sell-off
Nov 2022 – Oct 202311−30%−30%+4%+3%+205% (so far)Yes
May 2021 – Jun 202213−46%−23%−20%−10%+28%Yes
Nov 2017 – Mar 202028−52%−61%+1%−3%+185%Yes
Dec 2013 – Jun 201630−31%−19%+17%+13%+52%No
Nov 2010 – Sep 201110−41%−39%−4%−5%+103%Yes

Tesla: an automaker that trades like a tech stock

Tesla‘s swings, about ±55% around trend, are the largest of any carmaker, but its history since 2010 is too short and its moves too irregular for a reliable cycle. Its three major drawdowns (−49% in 2017–19, −68% in 2021–22 and −36% in early 2025) were followed by recoveries of +2,992%, +228% and +51% so far.

TSLA: major declines (monthly closes, reversals of 35% or more), latest first, with other symbols over the same months. "–" = no data for that period.
Peak – troughMonthsTSLAXLY same monthsSPY same monthsTSLA recovery to next peakDuring S&P sell-off
Jan 2025 – Mar 20252−36%−15%−7%+51% (so far)Yes
Nov 2021 – Dec 202213−68%−37%−16%+228%Yes
Jun 2017 – May 201923−49%+24%+14%+2,992%Yes

What this means for investors

  • Auto stocks amplify the economy: they fall first and hardest in recessions and tend to rebound sharply.
  • Ford’s 5.5-year rhythm is a useful reference for how long auto upswings and downswings have lasted, not a timer.
  • Industry shifts can override the cycle, as the electric-vehicle transition did for Ford in 2014–18.
  • The consumer discretionary fund is not an auto proxy: XLY is dominated by retailers and Amazon. See also cyclical industrial stocks.

How we measure a cycle: each symbol’s monthly closes are compared with their own long-term trend (a 10-year local regression of the log price). We then test every cycle length from 2 to 8 years and ask how often random price wandering with the same persistence produces a cycle at least as strong (120 simulations per symbol; this is the “chance it’s luck” column). Turning points are peaks and troughs separated by a reversal scaled to each symbol’s volatility. Prices exclude dividends. Full method in our guide to stock market cycles.

Frequently asked questions

Are auto stocks cyclical?

Yes, strongly. Car purchases are large and postponable, so sales and profits rise and fall with the economy and interest rates. Ford shows a measurable 5.5-year cycle in our data, with swings of about ±22% around its long-term trend.

How did auto stocks do in recessions?

They fell much more than the market: Ford lost 77% from April 2008 to January 2009 while SPY lost 40%, and GM and Ford both lost more than half their value between late 2017 and March 2020.

Is Tesla a cyclical stock?

Tesla is highly volatile, swinging about ±55% around its long-term trend, but its history is too short and its moves too irregular to show a reliable cycle. It has behaved more like a growth technology stock than a traditional automaker.

Do Ford and GM move together?

Largely yes. From November 2017 to March 2020 GM fell 52% and Ford 61%; from November 2022 to October 2023 both fell 30% while the broader market rose.

Which ETF tracks auto stocks?

Automakers belong to the consumer discretionary sector, tracked by the Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR (XLY), but XLY is dominated by Amazon, Tesla and Home Depot rather than carmakers. This is not a recommendation.

More market-cycle research

Figures are historical, based on monthly closing prices to mid-November 2026, and are updated as new data arrives. Past cycles do not predict future returns; this is research, not investment advice.