Gold mining stocks have a reputation for spectacular booms and painful busts. Our cycle analysis confirms it: the miners have the largest regular swings of any group on the site, and they follow a rhythm of their own that has little to do with the S&P 500. We compared five long-history gold and silver miners with the VanEck Gold Miners ETF (GDX), with gold itself through the SPDR Gold Shares ETF (GLD), and with SPY.
- Newmont, Hecla Mining and Kinross Gold have some of the clearest multi-year cycles on the site; Hecla’s and Newmont’s have under a 1% chance of being luck.
- The swings are huge: Hecla moves about ±39% around its long-term trend, Kinross ±33%, Wheaton Precious Metals ±29%, Newmont and Agnico Eagle ±20%. The S&P 500 moves about ±11%.
- Miners amplify gold: in 2011–15 GDX lost 78% while gold fell 43%; in 2008 GDX fell 61% while gold fell 26%.
- Miners barely move with stocks: the correlation of GDX’s swings with SPY’s is just 0.13, and Newmont’s, Kinross’s and Agnico Eagle’s are slightly negative.
- But they are not a crash hedge: in the 2008 and 2020 sell-offs, GDX fell as much as or more than SPY.
Why gold mining stocks are so cyclical
A miner’s costs (labour, energy, equipment, royalties) are largely fixed in the short run, while its revenue moves with the gold price. That operating leverage means a 10% rise in gold can lift profits far more than 10%, and a fall can wipe them out. Add the cycle of exploration spending, mine development, acquisitions and write-downs, and you get boom-and-bust swings that last several years: the 2001–11 bull market, the 2011–15 bear market, the 2016–20 recovery, the 2020–22 pullback and the rally that followed.
Five miners against GDX, gold and SPY
Each line shows how far the monthly close sat above or below its own long-term trend. Turn GDX, GLD and SPY on in the legend to compare them with the individual miners.
| Symbol | Name | Complete years | Strongest cycle | Chance it's luck | Cycle rating | Swing around trend | Typical peak spacing | Declines during S&P sell-offs | Moves with GDX | Moves with SPY |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NEM | Newmont Corporation | 53 | 7.8 yrs | <1% | Moderate | ±20% | 3.5 yrs | 11 of 16 | 0.90 | -0.08 |
| HL | Hecla Mining Co | 53 | 4.6 yrs | <1% | Moderate | ±39% | 2.3 yrs | 11 of 23 | 0.71 | 0.07 |
| KGC | Kinross Gold Corp | 44 | 7.8 yrs | 3% | Moderate | ±33% | 1.7 yrs | 13 of 18 | 0.83 | -0.19 |
| WPM | Wheaton Precious Metals Corp. | 21 | 4.8 yrs | 5% | Strong | ±29% | 3.4 yrs | 4 of 5 | 0.85 | 0.41 |
| AEM | Agnico Eagle Mines Ltd | 53 | 7.7 yrs | 6% | Weak | ±20% | 2.4 yrs | 11 of 19 | 0.75 | -0.14 |
| FCX | Freeport-McMoRan Inc | 30 | 3.5 yrs | 24% | None | ±24% | 2.3 yrs | 8 of 12 | 0.34 | 0.33 |
| GLD | SPDR Gold Shares ETF | 21 | 4.6 yrs | 16% | Weak | ±9% | 4.5 yrs | 3 of 4 | 0.91 | 0.09 |
The miners move together (correlations with GDX of 0.71–0.90) and with gold (GLD’s swings correlate 0.91 with GDX’s), but hardly at all with SPY. Wheaton Precious Metals, a streaming company that buys future metal output rather than running mines, is the only one rated strong: its peaks have been unusually regularly spaced, about every 3.4 years. Freeport-McMoRan, mainly a copper miner, behaves differently: its cycle follows industrial metals and the economy more than gold.
Spotlight: Newmont, the largest gold miner
Newmont has a long, slow cycle of about 7.8 years (under a 1% chance of luck), swinging roughly ±20% around trend. Its biggest drawdowns were the 2011–14 bust (−73%, while gold fell 34% and SPY rose 66%) and a 61% fall from March 2022 to February 2024, when gold was actually up 5%: rising costs and a large acquisition weighed on the shares even as the metal held firm.
| Peak – trough | Months | NEM | GDX same months | GLD same months | SPY same months | NEM recovery to next peak | During S&P sell-off |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 2024 – Dec 2024 | 3 | −30% | −15% | −0% | +2% | +204% (so far) | Yes |
| Mar 2022 – Feb 2024 | 23 | −61% | −31% | +5% | +12% | +71% | Yes |
| Jul 2016 – Sep 2018 | 26 | −31% | −39% | −13% | +34% | +163% | Yes |
| May 2015 – Sep 2015 | 4 | −41% | −30% | −6% | −9% | +174% | No |
| Nov 2011 – Nov 2014 | 36 | −73% | −70% | −34% | +66% | +48% | Yes |
| Jan 2008 – Oct 2008 | 9 | −51% | −58% | −22% | −30% | +162% | Yes |
| Jan 2006 – Jun 2007 | 17 | −37% | – | +13% | +18% | +39% | No |
| Sep 1999 – Oct 2000 | 13 | −48% | – | – | +11% | +356% | Yes |
Hecla Mining: the biggest swings on the site
Hecla Mining, one of the oldest U.S. silver miners, has the clearest cycle of any symbol we tested: about 4.6 years, under a 1% chance of luck, with swings of about ±39% around trend. It also has the most major drawdowns, 23 since the 1970s, including an 80% fall from 2016 to 2019 and a 67% fall in 2012–14 that GDX matched. Recoveries were equally dramatic: +604% from the February 2024 low to the next peak.
| Peak – trough | Months | HL | GDX same months | SPY same months | HL recovery to next peak | During S&P sell-off |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Feb 2026 – Jul 2026 | 5 | −43% | −36% | +9% | −7% (so far) | No |
| Mar 2023 – Feb 2024 | 11 | −44% | −19% | +24% | +604% | No |
| May 2021 – Jun 2022 | 13 | −56% | −31% | −10% | +61% | Yes |
| Dec 2019 – Mar 2020 | 3 | −46% | −21% | −20% | +395% | Yes |
| Jul 2016 – May 2019 | 34 | −80% | −29% | +27% | +159% | Yes |
| Feb 2015 – Jan 2016 | 11 | −44% | −33% | −8% | +249% | No |
| Oct 2012 – Oct 2014 | 24 | −67% | −67% | +43% | +52% | No |
| Dec 2010 – May 2012 | 17 | −62% | −29% | +5% | +55% | Yes |
How SPY behaved around the gold-miner cycle
GDX’s major drawdowns tell the story of a sector that runs on its own clock. During the long 2011–15 bust, the S&P 500 gained 67%; during the 2016–18 decline it gained 34%; and from February to July 2026, while GDX fell 36% and gold 23%, SPY rose 9%. But when the stock market itself crashed, as in 2008, miners did not protect investors: GDX fell 61% from February to October 2008 against SPY’s 28%.
| Peak – trough | Months | GDX | GLD same months | SPY same months | GDX recovery to next peak | During S&P sell-off |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Feb 2026 – Jul 2026 | 5 | −36% | −23% | +9% | +10% (so far) | No |
| Mar 2022 – Aug 2022 | 5 | −38% | −12% | −13% | +387% | Yes |
| Jul 2020 – Sep 2021 | 14 | −31% | −11% | +31% | +30% | No |
| Jul 2016 – Sep 2018 | 26 | −39% | −13% | +34% | +132% | Yes |
| Aug 2011 – Dec 2015 | 52 | −78% | −43% | +67% | +123% | Yes |
| Feb 2008 – Oct 2008 | 8 | −61% | −26% | −28% | +200% | Yes |
So gold miners are a diversifier, not a hedge: their cycles rarely line up with the stock market’s, but in a liquidity panic they tend to fall with everything else before recovering faster.
What this means for investors
- Size positions for ±30–40% swings. Even the largest miners have halved several times.
- The gold price drives the cycle, costs decide the amplitude. Newmont fell 61% in 2022–24 while gold rose.
- Low correlation with SPY makes miners useful diversifiers in a portfolio, but not reliable protection in a crash.
- Miners have long cycles (4.5–8 years), so being early can mean years of waiting.
How we measure a cycle: each symbol’s monthly closes are compared with their own long-term trend (a 10-year local regression of the log price). We then test every cycle length from 2 to 8 years and ask how often random price wandering with the same persistence produces a cycle at least as strong (120 simulations per symbol; this is the “chance it’s luck” column). Turning points are peaks and troughs separated by a reversal scaled to each symbol’s volatility. Prices exclude dividends. Full method in our guide to stock market cycles.
Frequently asked questions
Because of operating leverage: a miner’s costs are largely fixed, so changes in the gold price have an outsized effect on profits. In our data GDX lost 78% in 2011–15 while gold fell 43%, and individual miners such as Hecla swing about ±39% around their long-term trend.
Mostly not. The correlation of GDX’s swings with SPY’s is only 0.13, and Newmont’s and Kinross’s are slightly negative. Miners fell while the S&P 500 rose in 2011–15, 2016–18 and early 2026, but they fell with the market in the 2008 and 2020 crashes.
Between about 4.5 and 8 years for the stocks we tested: Hecla 4.6 years, Wheaton 4.8 years, Newmont and Kinross about 7.8 years. GDX itself shows a 4.8-year rhythm, though its history (since 2006) is too short for a confident rating.
Historically, no. In 2008 GDX fell 61% against SPY’s 28% decline over the same months, and in early 2020 both fell about 20%. Gold itself held up better than the miners in both episodes.
GLD holds physical gold and tracks the gold price; GDX holds shares of gold mining companies. In our data GDX has moved roughly twice as much as gold or more in its big declines (−78% against −43% in 2011–15) because of the miners’ operating leverage and company-specific risks.
More market-cycle research
- Stock market cycles: what 55 years of data show
- Cyclical stocks: industrials and the 3.5-year business cycle
- Defensive stocks have cycles too: consumer staples
- Healthcare stocks and market cycles: pharma, biotech and XLV
- Semiconductor stocks and the chip cycle
- Oil stocks and the oil price cycle
- Auto stocks and the car cycle: Ford, GM, Toyota and Tesla
- Tech stocks and market cycles: XLK and the Nasdaq
- Which stocks follow the S&P 500’s seasonal pattern?
Figures are historical, based on monthly closing prices to mid-November 2026, and are updated as new data arrives. Past cycles do not predict future returns; this is research, not investment advice.
