Defensive Stocks Have Cycles Too: Consumer Staples’ 5- to 8-Year Waves (Altria, PepsiCo, P&G vs XLP and SPY)

Consumer staples have the highest share of measurable multi-year cycles of any sector. We compare Altria, PepsiCo, Procter & Gamble, Kimberly-Clark and others with XLP and SPY.

Defensive stocks are supposed to be the steady part of a portfolio: people buy toothpaste, cereal and soft drinks whatever the economy does. Yet when we tested every long-history stock on the site for repeating multi-year cycles, consumer staples had the highest share of measurable cycles of any sector: 9 of 15. Their waves are slow, about five to eight years long, and they are driven less by the economy than by investors rotating into and out of safety. We compared the clearest examples with the Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR fund (XLP) and with SPY.

  • Altria and PepsiCo show 5-year cycles with under a 1% chance of luck; Procter & Gamble, Kimberly-Clark, Colgate-Palmolive, General Mills and Costco show 5–8-year cycles.
  • The swings are modest, typically ±7–13% around trend, but they repeat over five decades.
  • The XLP fund itself shows no reliable cycle (±4%): its members peak at different times, so their waves cancel out.
  • Staples protected investors in most crashes: XLP fell 30% in 2007–09 against SPY’s 50% and 13% in 2022 against 25%.
  • Their deepest drawdowns were company-specific: Altria fell 46% in 2017–19 and PepsiCo 31% in 2023–25 while SPY was rising.

Why defensive stocks have cycles

Staples companies have steady sales, so their cycles come mainly from valuation. In late-cycle markets and recessions, investors seek safety and dividends, and staples’ price-to-earnings ratios rise; in strong bull markets money rotates into faster-growing cyclical stocks and staples lag. Interest rates matter too: these are dividend payers that compete with bonds, so rising yields tend to weigh on them. This sector rotation between cyclical and defensive stocks takes years, which is why staples’ cycles are longer than industrials’ 3.5-year beat.

Six staples stocks against XLP and SPY

The lines show how far each stock sat above or below its own long-term trend. Notice how the waves are long and smooth compared with industrials or miners, and how they often move against the market: staples were above trend in 2000–02 and 2008, when the S&P 500 was in a bear market.

Consumer staples stocks: multi-year cycle statistics, with the Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR (XLP) and SPY. "Chance it's luck" = share of random-walk simulations producing a cycle at least as strong; correlations compare the swings around each symbol's long-term trend.
SymbolNameComplete yearsStrongest cycleChance it's luckCycle ratingSwing around trendTypical peak spacingDeclines during S&P sell-offsMoves with XLPMoves with SPY
MOAltria Group Inc535.0 yrs<1%Moderate±13%5.0 yrs8 of 100.640.23
PEPPepsiCo Inc535.0 yrs<1%Moderate±8%3.2 yrs7 of 140.780.43
PGProcter & Gamble Co537.5 yrs2%Moderate±7%2.7 yrs10 of 170.330.40
KMBKimberly-Clark Corporation534.8 yrs2%Moderate±8%2.7 yrs8 of 150.690.46
CLColgate-Palmolive Company537.7 yrs3%Moderate±7%3.8 yrs10 of 140.500.58
GISGeneral Mills Inc537.8 yrs4%Moderate±8%4.1 yrs9 of 140.450.06
COSTCostco Wholesale Corporation437.2 yrs2%Moderate±13%1.8 yrs7 of 120.400.68
TGTTarget Corporation537.3 yrs<1%Moderate±20%2.6 yrs11 of 150.450.57
KOThe Coca-Cola Company536.9 yrs22%None±7%1.9 yrs11 of 160.580.38
WMTWalmart Inc537.0 yrs13%Weak±11%5.4 yrs5 of 80.080.44
MDLZMondelez International Inc248.0 yrs12%Weak±6%2.0 yrs6 of 80.600.36

Two retailers are among the clearest cycles: Target (7.3 years, under a 1% chance of luck, ±20%) and Costco (7.2 years). Both move more with SPY than with XLP, a reminder that big-box retailers sit between staples and consumer discretionary. Coca-Cola and Walmart, two of the steadiest names, show no reliable period at all. General Mills’ swings are almost unrelated to the market’s (correlation 0.06), the most defensive profile in the group.

Spotlight: Altria, a defensive stock with deep cycles

Altria has a 5-year cycle that is among the most reliable on the site, with major peaks a median five years apart. Its swings are large for a staples stock, ±13% around trend, and several of its drawdowns had nothing to do with the market: from May 2017 to September 2019 the shares fell 46% while XLP rose 8% and SPY 23%, as smoking volumes declined and a large investment in an e-cigarette maker soured.

MO: major declines (monthly closes, reversals of 20% or more), latest first, with other symbols over the same months. "–" = no data for that period.
Peak – troughMonthsMOXLP same monthsSPY same monthsMO recovery to next peakDuring S&P sell-off
Apr 2022 – Jan 202421−28%−6%+17%+96% (so far)Yes
Dec 2019 – Oct 202010−28%−1%+1%+54%Yes
May 2017 – Sep 201928−46%+8%+23%+22%Yes
Nov 2007 – Dec 200813−37%−18%−39%+401%Yes
May 2002 – Mar 200310−48%−25%−21%+245%Yes
Nov 1998 – Feb 200015−64%–+18%+184%Yes
Sep 1992 – Sep 199312−46%––+266%No
Sep 1987 – May 19888−29%––+304%Yes

PepsiCo: a 5-year rhythm and a recent break

PepsiCo‘s cycle is also about 5 years long with under a 1% chance of luck, though with smaller swings (±8%). Half of its major drawdowns happened outside market sell-offs, and the latest is the clearest example: from April 2023 to May 2025 the stock fell 31% while XLP rose 7% and SPY 42%, as volumes weakened and investors favoured growth stocks.

PEP: major declines (monthly closes, reversals of 17% or more), latest first, with other symbols over the same months. "–" = no data for that period.
Peak – troughMonthsPEPXLP same monthsSPY same monthsPEP recovery to next peakDuring S&P sell-off
Apr 2023 – May 202525−31%+7%+42%+29%Yes
Nov 2007 – Feb 200915−38%−30%−50%+297%Yes
May 2002 – Sep 20024−29%−20%−24%+109%Yes
Dec 1998 – Sep 19999−26%–+4%+72%No
Mar 1998 – Aug 19985−35%–−13%+48%Yes
Jun 1996 – Sep 19963−20%–+2%+64%No

How SPY behaved around the consumer staples cycle

XLP’s own drawdowns show the defensive pattern. In the two big bear markets of this century the fund fell less than or the same as SPY (−30% against −50% in 2007–09; −35% against −35% in 2000–03), and in early 2020 it fell 14% against 20%. But staples also have drawdowns of their own when the market is fine: in 1999 XLP fell 23% while SPY rose 8% at the height of the technology boom, and in 2023 it fell 12% while SPY was flat.

XLP: major declines (monthly closes, reversals of 12% or more), latest first, with other symbols over the same months. "–" = no data for that period.
Peak – troughMonthsXLPSPY same monthsXLP recovery to next peakDuring S&P sell-off
Apr 2023 – Oct 20236−12%+1%+36% (so far)No
Apr 2022 – Sep 20225−14%−13%+16%Yes
Jan 2020 – Mar 20202−14%−20%+43%Yes
Jan 2018 – May 20184−14%−4%+27%No
Nov 2007 – Feb 200915−30%−50%+184%Yes
Dec 2000 – Mar 200327−35%−35%+57%Yes
Jan 1999 – Feb 200013−23%+8%+39%Yes

That is the defensive rotation in a nutshell: staples tend to lag in speculative booms and outperform when the market cycle turns down, which is exactly when investors value them most.

What this means for investors

  • Defensive does not mean flat. Individual staples stocks still swing ±7–20% around trend in multi-year waves, and some have halved.
  • Staples cycles are long. At five to eight years, a stock can lag the market for years before its next upswing.
  • The fund smooths the cycle. XLP’s ±4% swings are far smaller than its members’, because they peak at different times.
  • Most of the protection shows up in bear markets, while the biggest single-stock drawdowns were company-specific.

How we measure a cycle: each symbol’s monthly closes are compared with their own long-term trend (a 10-year local regression of the log price). We then test every cycle length from 2 to 8 years and ask how often random price wandering with the same persistence produces a cycle at least as strong (120 simulations per symbol; this is the “chance it’s luck” column). Turning points are peaks and troughs separated by a reversal scaled to each symbol’s volatility. Prices exclude dividends. Full method in our guide to stock market cycles.

Frequently asked questions

What are defensive stocks?

Defensive stocks are shares of companies whose sales hold up in recessions: consumer staples (food, beverages, household products, tobacco), healthcare and utilities. They usually fall less than the market in bear markets but lag in strong bull markets.

Do consumer staples stocks have cycles?

Yes. In our data 9 of 15 long-history consumer staples stocks show a measurable multi-year cycle, the highest share of any sector. The cycles are long (about 5–8 years) and modest (typically ±7–13% around trend), driven mainly by investors rotating into and out of defensive stocks.

How did consumer staples perform in bear markets?

Better than the market: XLP fell 30% in 2007–09 while SPY fell 50%, and 13% in 2022 while SPY fell 25%. In 2000–03 they fell about the same as the S&P 500.

Why did Altria and PepsiCo fall while the market rose?

Their deepest recent drawdowns were company-specific. Altria fell 46% in 2017–19 as smoking volumes declined and an investment in an e-cigarette maker soured; PepsiCo fell 31% in 2023–25 as volumes weakened and investors favoured growth stocks. In both periods SPY rose strongly.

What is the consumer staples ETF XLP?

The Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLP) holds the consumer staples companies in the S&P 500, including Procter & Gamble, Coca-Cola, PepsiCo, Walmart and Costco. It is the benchmark we compare against here; this is not a recommendation.

More market-cycle research

Figures are historical, based on monthly closing prices to mid-November 2026, and are updated as new data arrives. Past cycles do not predict future returns; this is research, not investment advice.