Oil Stocks and the Oil Price Cycle: Exxon, Chevron, ConocoPhillips and SLB vs XLE, Crude Oil and the S&P 500

Oil stocks follow crude oil's boom-and-bust cycle more than the stock market's. We compare Exxon Mobil, Chevron, ConocoPhillips, EOG and SLB with XLE, crude oil and SPY.

Oil stocks rise and fall with the price of crude, and crude moves in long, violent cycles of shortage and glut. We measured the multi-year cycles of the major U.S. and European oil companies and oilfield-services firms and compared them with the Energy Select Sector SPDR fund (XLE), with crude oil through the United States Oil Fund (USO) and Brent oil fund (BNO), and with SPY.

  • XLE shows a 5.7-year oil cycle (about an 8% chance of luck) with swings of about ±16% around trend.
  • Most oil majors show weak cycles of 3.5–6 years: Exxon Mobil 5.2, Chevron 3.5, ConocoPhillips 5.5, EOG 4.2, Devon 3.6. BP’s 4.5-year cycle passes our test (about a 5% chance of luck); so does the Brent oil fund’s 4.5-year cycle, though its history is short.
  • Oil producers and services companies move together (correlations with XLE of 0.78–0.92) but only loosely with the market: Occidental’s swings are essentially unrelated to SPY’s (0.02).
  • The worst oil busts happened while the stock market was fine: from June 2014 to February 2016 XLE lost 43% and USO 77% while SPY was flat; SLB lost 89% between 2014 and 2020 while SPY rose 32%.
  • In market crashes oil stocks fell too: XLE −54% against SPY −42% from June 2008 to February 2009.

What drives the oil price cycle?

High prices encourage drilling and investment and discourage consumption; years later the new supply arrives just as demand has slowed, and prices collapse. Low prices then cut investment, and the cycle turns again. OPEC decisions, wars, recessions and the U.S. shale boom have all shaped recent cycles: the 2008 spike and crash, the 2014–16 glut, the 2020 pandemic collapse (when U.S. crude briefly traded below zero) and the 2021–22 rebound. Oilfield-services companies such as SLB and Halliburton depend on drilling budgets and swing even more than producers; refiners such as Valero follow refining margins rather than crude itself.

Oil stocks against XLE, crude oil and SPY

Oil and gas stocks: multi-year cycle statistics, with the Energy Select Sector SPDR (XLE) and SPY. "Chance it's luck" = share of random-walk simulations producing a cycle at least as strong; correlations compare the swings around each symbol's long-term trend.
SymbolNameComplete yearsStrongest cycleChance it's luckCycle ratingSwing around trendTypical peak spacingDeclines during S&P sell-offsMoves with XLEMoves with SPY
XOMExxon Mobil Corporation535.2 yrs11%Weak±8%3.3 yrs10 of 130.880.41
CVXChevron Corporation563.5 yrs8%Weak±8%3.2 yrs12 of 150.880.43
COPConocoPhillips535.5 yrs8%Weak±12%3.8 yrs11 of 140.920.38
EOGEOG Resources Inc364.3 yrs8%Weak±17%2.8 yrs8 of 110.850.21
OXYOccidental Petroleum Corp534.3 yrs11%Weak±15%2.3 yrs10 of 160.780.02
DVNDevon Energy Corporation373.6 yrs7%Weak±22%2.8 yrs8 of 120.820.29
SLBSLB (Schlumberger)535.3 yrs17%None±14%3.3 yrs12 of 140.890.50
HALHalliburton Company538.0 yrs26%None±16%3.0 yrs12 of 140.850.52
VLOValero Energy Corporation285.5 yrs36%None±22%4.2 yrs7 of 70.750.43
WMBThe Williams Companies Inc536.4 yrs14%Weak±21%2.5 yrs11 of 130.630.74
BPBP plc414.5 yrs5%Moderate±13%3.0 yrs8 of 120.610.31
SHELShell plc416.0 yrs21%None±9%1.9 yrs8 of 100.870.49
TTETotalEnergies SE225.3 yrs39%Weak±29%5.2 yrs2 of 30.590.60
PBRPetrobras - Petroleo Brasileiro SA255.9 yrs49%None±19%2.4 yrs4 of 70.640.33

The integrated majors (Exxon Mobil, Chevron, Shell) have the smallest swings, about ±8–9% around trend, because refining and chemicals cushion low oil prices. Exploration and production companies swing more (Devon ±22%, EOG ±17%), and services companies and refiners more still. TotalEnergies’ turning points have been the most regular in the group, about five years apart.

XLE against crude oil and SPY

The energy sector fund’s drawdowns show how oil stocks absorb part, but not all, of the oil price cycle. In 2014–16 crude oil (USO) lost 77% and XLE 43%; in 2018–20 crude lost 71% and XLE 62%; in 2008, 76% against 54%. SPY fell in only some of these episodes.

XLE: major declines (monthly closes, reversals of 20% or more), latest first, with other symbols over the same months. "–" = no data for that period.
Peak – troughMonthsXLEUSO same monthsSPY same monthsXLE recovery to next peakDuring S&P sell-off
May 2020 – Oct 20205−26%−2%+7%+352% (so far)Yes
Jul 2018 – Mar 202020−62%−71%−8%+33%Yes
Jun 2014 – Feb 201620−43%−77%−1%+36%No
Apr 2011 – Sep 20115−27%−32%−17%+71%Yes
Jun 2008 – Feb 20098−54%−76%−42%+96%Yes
Apr 2001 – Sep 200217−38%–−35%+318%Yes

Spotlight: ConocoPhillips and SLB

ConocoPhillips, a pure oil and gas producer, tracks XLE more closely than any other stock (correlation 0.92). It lost 60% in 2008, 61% in 2014–16 and 53% in early 2020, then gained 345% from the October 2020 low. SLB, the largest oilfield-services company, shows how long an energy bust can last: from June 2014 to March 2020 it lost 89% over 69 months while SPY gained 32%.

COP: major declines (monthly closes, reversals of 24% or more), latest first, with other symbols over the same months. "–" = no data for that period.
Peak – troughMonthsCOPXLE same monthsUSO same monthsSPY same monthsCOP recovery to next peakDuring S&P sell-off
Mar 2024 – May 202514−33%−14%−15%+13%+67% (so far)Yes
May 2020 – Oct 20205−32%−26%−2%+7%+345%Yes
Dec 2019 – Mar 20203−53%−52%−67%−20%+37%Yes
Sep 2018 – Aug 201911−33%−24%−26%+1%+25%Yes
Jun 2014 – Feb 201620−61%−43%−77%−1%+129%No
Jun 2008 – Feb 20098−60%−54%−76%−42%+201%Yes
SLB: major declines (monthly closes, reversals of 26% or more), latest first, with other symbols over the same months. "–" = no data for that period.
Peak – troughMonthsSLBXLE same monthsSPY same monthsSLB recovery to next peakDuring S&P sell-off
Aug 2023 – May 202521−44%−8%+31%+56% (so far)Yes
Jun 2014 – Mar 202069−89%−71%+32%+337%Yes
Feb 2011 – Sep 20117−36%−25%−15%+97%Yes
Jun 2008 – Feb 20098−65%−54%−42%+145%Yes
Sep 2007 – Jan 20084−28%−7%−10%+42%Yes

What this means for investors

  • Oil stocks diversify an equity portfolio because their cycle follows crude, not the stock market, but they still fall in recessions.
  • The majors are the defensive end of the sector; producers, services and refiners amplify the oil cycle.
  • Busts can last years: 2014–16 and 2018–20 were long, slow declines, not short crashes.
  • Watch supply as much as demand: investment cuts in a bust plant the seeds of the next boom.

How we measure a cycle: each symbol’s monthly closes are compared with their own long-term trend (a 10-year local regression of the log price). We then test every cycle length from 2 to 8 years and ask how often random price wandering with the same persistence produces a cycle at least as strong (120 simulations per symbol; this is the “chance it’s luck” column). Turning points are peaks and troughs separated by a reversal scaled to each symbol’s volatility. Prices exclude dividends. Full method in our guide to stock market cycles.

Frequently asked questions

Are oil stocks cyclical?

Yes. Oil company profits depend on the price of crude, which moves in multi-year cycles of shortage and glut. The energy fund XLE shows a 5.7-year cycle in our data, and most oil majors show weak cycles of 3.5–6 years with swings of ±8–22% around trend.

How long is the oil price cycle?

In our data the energy sector cycles roughly every five to six years (XLE 5.7 years, ConocoPhillips 5.5, Exxon Mobil 5.2), with the Brent oil fund at about 4.5 years. Individual booms and busts have varied a lot, from the short 2020 crash to the five-year 2014–2020 slump in oilfield services.

Do oil stocks move with the S&P 500?

Only loosely. XLE’s swings correlate 0.46 with SPY’s, and Occidental’s just 0.02. In 2014–16 XLE fell 43% while SPY was flat; in 2008 both fell sharply.

How much do oil stocks fall when oil crashes?

Less than oil itself: in 2014–16 crude (USO) fell 77% and XLE 43%; in 2018–20 crude fell 71% and XLE 62%. Oilfield-services stocks fell more: SLB lost 89% from 2014 to 2020.

What is the main oil and gas sector ETF?

The Energy Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLE), which holds the energy companies in the S&P 500, led by Exxon Mobil and Chevron. USO and BNO track crude oil futures rather than oil companies. This is not a recommendation.

More market-cycle research

Figures are historical, based on monthly closing prices to mid-November 2026, and are updated as new data arrives. Past cycles do not predict future returns; this is research, not investment advice.